Consumer finance · American Express vs Coinbase · to 2026-10-23

AXP vs COIN stock comparison

→American Express (AXP) is 4.8 times the size of Coinbase (COIN) at $210.0B against $43.4B, and American Express passes more of the TenQ Score checks, 19 of 36 against 14.

AXP -10.8% · COIN -49.0% over 1Y
37.859.280.5101.8123.1Oct '25Jan '26Mar '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '26
The TenQ Radar

TenQ Score: AXP vs COIN

Each company is scored on the same checks, computed from its own filings: value, growth, quality, financial health, shareholder returns and trend. The fuller the shape, the more checks it passes.

→The two are furthest apart on Shareholder returns, where American Express passes 3 more checks.

All checksAXP19/36COIN14/36

→American Express brings in $77.6B of revenue a year to Coinbase's $6.3B, 12.3 times as much. Coinbase has not made a profit over the last twelve months, so their profits cannot be compared yet.

American Express files as a bank and Coinbase as an operating company, so some measures fit one and not the other: the charts below keep to the ones both report. The TenQ Score still compares, because each company is scored on the checks its own filings support.

I

Value: AXP vs COIN

AXP3/6COIN2/6

Coinbase has no profit to price, so the two are compared on revenue instead: a price to sales of 2.7x at American Express and 6.9x at Coinbase.

17.8xAXP-COINwhat you pay per $1 of profit
2.7xAXP6.9xCOINwhat you pay per $1 of revenue
6.6%AXP4.0%COINcash earned per $ of price
-AXP46.4xCOINwhole-business multiple
Valuation history

Is AXP or COIN more expensive against its earnings, sales and book value?

→AXP's latest price to earnings is 17.8x (2026), against 63.6x at COIN (2025).

What this measures

What the market has paid for each dollar of earnings, sales or book value, every year, with today's multiple as the last point and the median drawn across.

What good looks like. There is no good level. What matters is the distance from the company's own history, and whether the business has changed enough to justify it.

If it rises or falls. A multiple above its own median means the market expects more than it used to, so more has to go right. Below the median means the opposite, and the question is whether the pessimism is deserved. A multiple can also fall because earnings rose, which is the good way.

What does “Value” actually mean?

Value asks what you pay for each dollar of earnings, sales or cash a business produces. A high multiple is not automatically bad, since fast growers can earn theirs, but a price far above a company's own history means the market expects a lot to go right. Each company is measured against its own past and its sector.

How each scored · AXP 3/6 · COIN 2/6

Value, check by check

AXPCOIN
Cheaper than its own history (earnings)AXPFails17.79 vs 15.28COINPasses6.90 vs 7.46
Earnings yield beats the 10-year Treasury (5.1%)AXPPasses5.6% vs 5.1%COINFails6.90 vs 2.50 (fixed yardstick)
Better cash yield than its own historyAXPFails6.6% vs 13.4%COINFails6.45 vs 3.00 (fixed yardstick)
Hands back over 3% in dividends and buybacksAXPPasses4.4% vs 3.0%COINPasses4.0% vs 3.0%
Cheap on book value (under 1.3x)AXPFails5.87 vs 1.30 (fixed yardstick)COINFails46.43 vs 14.00 (fixed yardstick)
Price isn't outrunning growthAXPPassesPEG 1.12COINFailsno positive three-year earnings growth behind the price
II

Growth: AXP vs COIN

AXP2/6COIN2/6

American Express grew revenue faster over the last twelve months, +10.2% against -10.4% at Coinbase, 21 percentage points apart. Over three years the order is reversed: Coinbase grew +31.0% a year against +11.0% at American Express.

+10.2%AXP-10.4%COINvs the year before
+11.0%AXP+31.0%COINa year, compounded
+16.3%AXP-134.5%COINnet income growth
+13.0%AXP-COINa year, compounded
Revenue history

Is AXP or COIN growing revenue faster?

→On the latest figures, AXP's revenue is $77.6B, against $6.3B at COIN.

What this measures

The money customers paid, before any costs are taken out. Each bar is one quarter or, on the annual view, a full financial year; the last annual bar may be the trailing twelve months, which the footnote marks.

What good looks like. Growth that repeats, rather than one strong year carrying the chart, and a trailing twelve months keeping pace with the last full year.

If it rises or falls. Revenue is the hardest line to flatter, so a rise is the most trustworthy kind of growth. A fall puts pressure on every margin below it, because costs rarely come down as quickly as sales do.

Profit history

Is AXP or COIN growing its net profit faster?

→On the latest figures, AXP's net profit is $12.3B, against -$988M at COIN.

What this measures

What is left after every cost, including tax and interest. The bottom line of the income statement.

What good looks like. Profit growing at least as fast as revenue, which means the business is keeping more of each sale as it gets bigger.

If it rises or falls. Profit can move for reasons revenue cannot explain - a one-off charge, a tax change, a write-down - so a single sharp year is worth checking against the margin chart before reading it as a trend.

Growth rate

How fast is revenue growing at AXP and at COIN?

→AXP's latest revenue growth is 10.2% (Q3 2026), against -10.4% at COIN (Q2 2026).

What this measures

How much revenue and earnings changed against the year before - the trailing twelve months against the twelve before them at each quarter, or one point per fiscal year. It is the speed of the business, not its size.

What good looks like. The earnings line above the revenue line: profits growing faster than sales means each new dollar of sales arrives more profitably than the last.

If it rises or falls. A high growth rate off a small base is easy and gets harder every year, so slowing growth in a large business is normal rather than a warning. Earnings falling while revenue grows is the combination worth understanding: costs are rising faster than sales.

Per-share growth

Is revenue per share growing faster at AXP or COIN?

→AXP's latest revenue per share is $115.11 (Q3 2026), against $23.85 at COIN (Q2 2026).

What this measures

Revenue and free cash flow, each divided by the number of shares in issue and adjusted for splits so old and new years compare honestly. Both lines rising means each share owns more of the business's sales and cash.

What good looks like. Both lines rising, and revenue per share growing at least as fast as the company's total revenue, which the answer compares. Faster means buybacks are working for you; slower means new shares are absorbing part of the growth.

If it rises or falls. This is the line that actually reaches you. A company can grow revenue every year and still shrink your slice by issuing shares faster than it grows.

What does “Growth” actually mean?

Growth here is what each company has reported to the SEC, not a forecast: the last year, the three-year pace, and whether growth is speeding up or slowing down. Both companies are measured the same way, so their lines can be read against each other.

How each scored · AXP 2/6 · COIN 2/6

Growth, check by check

AXPCOIN
Outgrew its sector over the last twelve monthsAXPFails10.2% vs 34.4% (sector 70th pct, n=81)COINFails-10.4% vs 34.4% (sector 70th pct, n=81)
Sustained growth beats its sector (3 years)AXPFails11.0% vs 23.4% (sector 70th pct, n=64)COINPasses31.0% vs 23.4% (sector 70th pct, n=64)
Profits grew over the last twelve monthsAXPPasses16.3% vs 0.0%COINFails-134.5% vs 0.0%
Profit growth beats its sector (3 years)AXPFails13.0% vs 16.4% (sector 70th pct, n=51)COINFailsloss-making: TTM net income -$988M
Growth is speeding up, not slowingAXPFailslast twelve months 10.2% vs three-year pace 11.0%COINFailslast twelve months -10.4% vs three-year pace 31.0%
Grew per share, not just in totalAXPPasses47.6% vs 0.0%COINPasses74.0% vs 0.0%
III

Quality: AXP vs COIN

AXP4/6COIN2/6

Coinbase keeps more of each sale: a operating margin of 9.9% against 7.0%, 3 percentage points more on every dollar of revenue.

-AXP-COINkept after direct costs
7.0%AXP9.9%COINkept after running costs
36.1%AXP-7.1%COINprofit on shareholders' money
$13.9BAXP$1.7BCOINlast 12 months
Margins

Which keeps more of each sale as profit, AXP or COIN?

→AXP's latest net margin is 15.8% (Q3 2026), against -15.7% at COIN (Q2 2026).

What this measures

What survives at three points on the way down the income statement: after the direct cost of the product, after the cost of running the company, and after everything.

What good looks like. Margins that hold or widen as the business grows. The level itself varies enormously by industry, so the shape over time tells you more than the number.

If it rises or falls. A widening margin means pricing power or costs under control. A compressing one means the opposite, and it compounds: on large revenue, two points of margin is a great deal of profit.

Earnings quality

Does profit turn into cash better at AXP or COIN?

→On the latest figures, AXP's operating cash per dollar of profit is 1.7x, against 1.9x at COIN.

What this measures

Reported profit against the cash the business actually collected from operating. Profit is an accounting judgement; cash is not.

What good looks like. Cash at or above profit, year after year. Depreciation and other non-cash charges usually push cash above profit, so roughly 100% or more is healthy.

If it rises or falls. Cash falling behind profit for more than a year is the classic early warning: the sales are booked but the money has not arrived, and it shows up in receivables and inventory. For a lender the comparison behaves differently, because a growing loan book consumes cash.

Returns on capital

Which earns a higher return on its capital, AXP or COIN?

→AXP's latest return on equity is 36.1% (Q3 2026), against -7.1% at COIN (Q2 2026).

What this measures

Two returns side by side: on shareholders' capital (ROE), and on all the capital in the business including debt (ROCE).

What good looks like. Both comfortably above roughly 10%, and close together. A wide gap means borrowing, not operations, is doing the work.

If it rises or falls. A high ROE built on debt looks like quality until the debt has to be refinanced. ROCE is the harder number to flatter, which is why both are shown.

What does “Quality” actually mean?

Quality asks whether growth turns into real money: how much of each sale is kept as profit, whether that profit arrives as cash, and what return the business earns on the money invested in it.

How each scored · AXP 4/6 · COIN 2/6

Quality, check by check

AXPCOIN
Wider interest margin than its sectorAXPPasses6.1% vs 2.5% (sector 70th pct, n=39)COINFails-15.7% vs 14.2% (sector 70th pct, n=80)
Runs leaner than its sector (efficiency ratio)AXPFails74.0% vs 30.2% (sector 30th pct, n=20)COINPasses9.9% vs 6.4% (sector 70th pct, n=49)
Actually profitableAXPPassesTTM net income $12.3BCOINFailsTTM net income -$988M
Earns well on shareholders' moneyAXPPasses36.1% vs 11.9% (sector 70th pct, n=92)COINFails-7.1% vs 11.9% (sector 70th pct, n=92)
Earns a real return on shareholders' capitalAXPPasses36.1% vs 10.0%COINFails3.2% vs 10.0%
Credit costs stay containedAXPFails31.2% vs 2.4% (market 30th pct)COINPassesTTM operating cash flow $1.7B on a net loss of $988M
IV

Financial health: AXP vs COIN

AXP3/6COIN5/6

Coinbase carries far less debt for its size, 0.45x of debt for each dollar of equity against 1.67x. The gap matters most in a bad year.

1.67xAXP0.45xCOINborrowed vs owned
-AXP2.4xCOINnear-term bills coverage
1xAXP7xCOINearnings ÷ interest bill
$43.4BAXP$8.8BCOINcash plus short-term investments
Debt & cash

How much debt do AXP and COIN carry, against the cash they hold?

→On the latest figures, AXP's total debt is $60.0B, against $5.9B at COIN.

What this measures

Total borrowings against cash on hand, with debt as a multiple of shareholders' equity, and how many times profit covers the interest bill.

What good looks like. Interest covered comfortably - roughly eight times or more - and debt that is not a large multiple of equity.

If it rises or falls. Debt is only a problem when it has to be repaid or refinanced in a bad year, so cover matters more than the amount. Rising debt with rising cover is a business borrowing to grow; rising debt with falling cover is the combination that ends badly.

Shareholders' equity

Is shareholders' equity growing faster at AXP or COIN?

→On the latest figures, AXP's shareholders' equity is $35.8B, against $13.1B at COIN.

What this measures

What would be left for shareholders if every asset were sold at its book value and every debt repaid. Book value, in other words.

What good looks like. Equity growing as retained profits build up, unless the company is deliberately returning more than it earns.

If it rises or falls. Equity falls for two very different reasons: buybacks, which return money to you, and losses, which do not. The distinction is the whole story, and negative equity means liabilities now exceed assets, which makes debt-to-equity and return on equity meaningless rather than alarming.

What does “Financial health” actually mean?

Financial health asks one question: could the business get through a bad year? It looks at how much each company has borrowed, how easily its profits cover the interest, and how much cash it holds against the bills due soon.

How each scored · AXP 3/6 · COIN 5/6

Financial health, check by check

AXPCOIN
Capitalised wellAXPPasses11.5% vs 6.0%COINPasses2.42 vs 1.50
Lends less than it takes in depositsAXPNot scoredloans or deposits not reportedCOINPasses0.45 vs 1.00
Debt trending the right wayAXPPassesdebt/equity 1.67 now vs 1.85 five years agoCOINPassesdebt/equity 0.45 now vs 0.53 five years ago
The interest spread covers its credit lossesAXPFails0.31 vs 0.20COINPasses6.92 vs 5.00
Deposits are growing, not fleeingAXPPasses1.7% vs 0.0%COINFails27.3% vs 27.5% (sector 70th pct, n=81)
Reserves cover the loan book, better than the marketAXPNot scoredallowance for credit losses not reportedCOINPassesTTM free cash flow $1.7B
V

Shareholder returns: AXP vs COIN

AXP5/6COIN2/6

American Express pays a dividend yield of 1.2% at today's price and Coinbase pays almost nothing, the clearest difference in what each returns to shareholders.

+3.19%AXP+4.69%COINbought back, last 12 months, over market value
+1.21%AXP-COINat the current rate
$9.2BAXP$2.0BCOINdividends plus buybacks
$636MAXP$939MCOINlast 12 months, offsets buybacks
Capital returned

How much cash do AXP and COIN hand back to shareholders?

→On the latest figures, AXP's cash returned in dividends and buybacks is $8.1B, against $790M at COIN.

What this measures

Cash returned through buybacks and dividends, alongside the value of new shares issued to employees as compensation.

What good looks like. Returns comfortably larger than stock compensation, so the share count actually falls.

If it rises or falls. A company can announce billions in buybacks while issuing nearly as much stock to staff, and the two largely cancel. What reaches you is the net effect, which is why both bars are here rather than only the buyback.

Shareholder yield

Which pays shareholders the higher yield, AXP or COIN, counting buybacks?

→On the latest figures, AXP's shareholder yield is 3.8%, against 1.0% at COIN.

What this measures

Dividends and buybacks, each as a percentage of what the company was worth that year. The dollar chart says how much came back; this says how much came back for the price.

What good looks like. A total that clears a couple of percent and holds. Which half it comes from matters less than whether it is sustained.

If it rises or falls. A yield rises when the price falls as readily as when the payout grows, so read a jump beside the price chart before treating it as generosity.

Share count change

Is the share count falling faster at AXP or COIN?

→AXP's latest change in share count is -2.7% (Q3 2026), against -5.6% at COIN (Q2 2026).

What this measures

The yearly change in the number of shares in issue, adjusted for splits so the years compare. A bar below zero is a falling share count, usually from buybacks; above zero, new shares were issued.

What good looks like. A flat or falling share count. Falling means each share you hold owns a little more of the business every year.

If it rises or falls. A rising count divides the same business among more owners, so your slice shrinks unless profits grow faster. This is the most direct chart on the page: it is your ownership, measured.

What does “Shareholder returns” actually mean?

Shareholder returns is the cash a company hands back to the people who own its shares, through dividends and by buying its own shares back, and whether the stock it issues to staff quietly undoes those buybacks.

How each scored · AXP 5/6 · COIN 2/6

Shareholder returns, check by check

AXPCOIN
Share count isn't climbingAXPPassesshares down 7.4% over 3 yearsCOINFailsshares up 29.2% over 3 years
Buybacks outpace the stock issued to staffAXPPasses$6.7B bought back vs $636M of stock compensationCOINPasses$2.0B bought back vs $939M of stock compensation
What it hands back fits inside its profitsAXPPasses75.1% vs 100.0%COINFails118.7% vs 100.0%
Meaningful yield to owners (dividends and buybacks)AXPPasses$9.2B returned, 4.4% of market valueCOINPasses$2.0B returned, 4.7% of market value
Reliable payer, never cutAXPFailspaid 10/10 years, worst year-on-year change -1.8%COINFails$2.0B bought back in the last twelve months, 0.00 the year before; no dividend
Dividend per share growing ahead of inflationAXPPasses57.8% vs 9.0%COINFails$2.0B vs 0.00 the year before; no dividend
VI

Trend: AXP vs COIN

AXP2/6COIN1/6
-3.8%AXP-8.9%COINthe long-term trend line
-6.3%AXP-1.8%COINshare price
-10.0%AXP-48.7%COINshare price
-17.7%AXP-54.5%COINdrawdown from the peak
Trend

Which way are AXP and COIN shares trending?

AXP
Price chart loads as you scroll…
COIN
Price chart loads as you scroll…

Charts by TradingView

→AXP is in a downtrend: the price is below the cloud where recent trading settled and that cloud is still falling. COIN is in a downtrend, with the price below the cloud where recent trading settled, though the cloud ahead has begun to turn up.

How the trend is worked out

Trend reads the share price only: where it sits against its own long-term averages and how it has moved against the S&P 500. It says nothing about the business, which the other chapters cover.

How each scored · AXP 2/6 · COIN 1/6

Trend, check by check

AXPCOIN
Price above its long-term trend bandAXPFails$313.22, below the bottom of the trend band of $322.71COINFails$164.45, below the bottom of the trend band of $167.48
Price above its short and medium-term averagesAXPFails$313.22 against the 9-day average at $315.57 and the 26-day average at $311.28COINFails$164.45 against the 9-day average at $174.41 and the 26-day average at $185.83
Short-term average above the medium-term oneAXPPasses9-day average $315.57 above the 26-day average $311.28, 3 trading days since they crossedCOINFails9-day average $174.41 below the 26-day average $185.83, 7 trading days since they crossed
The long-term trend band ahead is risingAXPFailsthe trend band already drawn for the next 26 trading days are fallingCOINPassesthe trend band already drawn for the next 26 trading days are rising
Price above where it stood 26 trading days agoAXPPasses$313.22 against $310.21 26 trading days agoCOINFails$164.45 against $173.97 26 trading days ago
Beating the S&P 500 over the last yearAXPFails-10.0% vs 15.0%COINFails-48.7% vs 15.0%